The question is this: How do you define pagan? Going from dictionary defintions, nine out of ten times the defintion is something to the effect of someone who is neither Christian, Jew or Muslim. While this defintion includes most of those who identify as pagan (with exception of those who practice both Christianity/Judaism/Islam and a pagan religion), it also includes many who generally wouldn't identify as pagan (such as atheists, Hindus, Buddhists, agnostics, etc...) Some, using a rather "pc" approach, would say anyone who identifies as pagan is. Personally, I lean more towards the dictionary definition, though I recognize that neither definition is terribley useful when trying to explain paganism and for most it comes down to a definition of their personal form of paganism, but if we had to come up with a large scale definition, what do you think it is?
Thanks for your time and letting me join your community.